The Knockouts have started on The Voice season 25, and while this season’s mega mentor is technically country superstar Keith Urban (he’s done some time as a Voice Australia coach, so he knows what he’s doing), it’s his wife, Academy Award-winning actress Nicole Kidman, who winds up doing a little mentoring during a Team Reba head-to-head — without ever even having to be in the room.

Reba McEntire pairs up R&B powerhouse Asher Havon with country/soul artist Tae Lewis for the first Knockout of the season. Almost immediately, we’re reminded why they’ve made it this far in the competition. Keith is particularly excited by Asher, who has decided to perform Toni Braxton’s “Un-break My Heart” since it hits so close to home after a recent break-up. Asher says he doesn’t even have to put on a character for this performance — this is all him. After his first run-through, although Keith is impressed by Asher’s “unique timbre,” he tells him that he could “own more by doing less.” In other words, he doesn’t need to give it all away up front. He should build to the big finish, and be more intentional with his runs.

Reba agrees. She tells Asher to “be still.” And once she offers this advice, she’s immediately reminded of the one and only Nicole Kidman: “Nic does it all the time,” she tells Asher, explaining that she’s name-checking her friend’s wife. “Nicole Kidman, when you watch her act, she’s still. But you know what’s not? Everything coming out of her eyes.” Reba wants Asher to lean on the emotion of the song rather than theatrics. When he runs through the song a second time and takes the be Nicole Kidman note to heart, he leaves Reba in tears.

It’s no surprise when Asher pulls the same thing off during the actual performance. All five of the coaches are up on their feet as Asher hits that money note at the end.

It’s not like Tae Lewis is any slouch, though. He performs Cody Johnson’s “Nothin’ On You” and also earns a standing ovation from the entire coaching panel. Afterward, Chance the Rapper tells both artists that those were some “of the best performances on this TV show, period. Ever.” And John Legend, who tells Asher that he’s “never seen an artist be able to sing that low with that much power,” notes that “whoever Reba does not choose, there is a place on Team Legend.” Is announcing your Steal ahead of time against the rules? Maybe. But no one seems to mind, since they’re all in agreement that both Asher and Tae should make it to the Playoffs.

Reba feels “like a proud mama” for both of them, but it’s no surprise when she gives the win to Asher Havon. Perhaps it was him nailing the Nicole Kidman school of acting that put her over the edge.

This story has a happy ending for everyone though — not only does John make good on his Steal promise, but Dan + Shay and Chance all want Tae Lewis on their teams. Tae very clearly wants to stay in the country lane, so his choice to move to Team Dan + Shay feels right.